Discover Fyodor Dostoevsky’s poignant short story, ‘An Honest Thief’, and read the complete tale online for free.
First published in 1848, An Honest Thief is one of Fyodor Dostoevsky’s early and brilliant forays into the psychological and moral landscape of St. Petersburg’s impoverished underclass. The story is narrated by Astafy Ivanovich, a kind-hearted former soldier who rents a corner of his room to Emelyan Ilyich, a hopeless, aging alcoholic who has sunk to the lowest rung of society. Emelyan is a pitiful figure, a “lost soul” who survives on handouts and vague promises of finding work, all while succumbing to his vice.
The plot turns when Astafy’s prized pair of riding breeches is stolen. All evidence, and his own simmering resentment, point directly to the desperate Emelyan. Yet, when confronted, the old man denies it with such pathetic conviction that Astafy is left in agonizing doubt. The story unfolds as a masterful study of guilt, compassion, and the search for redemption in the grimmest of circumstances. Dostoevsky, with his unparalleled insight into the Russian soul, explores whether a man can be both a thief and “honest,” whether a crime can be absolved by profound remorse, and what true Christian charity demands of us. It is a compact gem that contains the seeds of his later, grander explorations of sin and salvation.
On this page, you can experience this early Dostoevsky masterpiece. We offer the complete 1848 story for online reading.
Book Info
| Detail | Information |
|---|---|
| Title | An Honest Thief |
| Author | Fyodor Dostoevsky |
| Year of Publication | 1848 |
| Genre | Literary Fiction, Short Story, Psychological Realism |
| Language | English (Translation from Russian) |
| Legal Status | Public Domain |
| Format | Online Reading |
Read An Honest Thief Online
Delve into a tale of poverty and conscience. Begin this moving story by exploring the first pages interactively below.
This preview introduces the narrator and the pitiful Emelyan, but the full, tense drama of the theft and its haunting aftermath is available in the complete text for our subscribers.
A subscription unlocks this poignant story and our library of Russian literary classics. Confront the complex morality of the desperate.
About An Honest Thief
In this short form, Dostoevsky perfects the “philosophical anecdote,” using a simple incident to probe the deepest questions of human nature.
The Dostoevskian “Double”
Emelyan serves as a dark mirror for the narrator, Astafy. Astafy’s initial charity is tested by the theft, forcing him to confront his own judgment, anger, and capacity for forgiveness. Their relationship embodies the struggle between righteous indignation and compassionate humility.
Psychology of Guilt
The story is a clinic in the manifestations of a guilty conscience. Emelyan’s physical and mental deterioration after the theft, his cryptic behavior, and his final confession are portrayed with devastating psychological accuracy.
Themes of Poverty and Dignity
Dostoevsky paints a stark picture of the “yellowed, peeling” world of the St. Petersburg poor. The stolen breeches are not just an object, but a symbol of Astafy’s last shred of respectable property, making the crime a deeply personal violation of trust within a shared struggle for survival.
Redemption through Confession
The story’s power culminates in its conclusion. Emelyan’s deathbed confession is not a mere admission, but a desperate, sacred act of seeking absolution. It forces both characters—and the reader—to weigh the crime against the profound, soul-crushing remorse that follows.
Why Read An Honest Thief Today?
It is a perfect introduction to Dostoevsky’s world: concise, powerful, and thematically rich. It explores timeless questions about the nature of honesty, the burden of sin, and the obligation we have to the most broken among us, all within a perfectly crafted narrative frame.
FAQ
Is this a major Dostoevsky work?
It is a minor work in terms of length and scope, but major in its artistic perfection and thematic significance. It is highly regarded as one of his finest short stories.
What is the story’s tone?
It blends grim realism with deep pathos and a moral seriousness that borders on the spiritual. There is also a touch of Dostoevskian dark humor in the depiction of Emelyan’s drunken antics.
Who is the “honest thief”?
The title is deeply ironic. Emelyan is a thief, yet his subsequent torment and desperate need for forgiveness reveal a conscience that, in Dostoevsky’s Christian worldview, makes him more “honest” in spirit than many who hide their sins.
How does it reflect Dostoevsky’s life?
Written before his Siberian exile, it shows his early fascination with the psychology of the downtrodden and the criminal, themes that would dominate his later great novels.
Can I read it on my phone?
Absolutely. It is a short story designed to be read in one sitting, making it ideal for mobile reading.